Environmental Remediation

Environmental Law

Environmental Cleanup & Cost Recovery AttorneyGlendale & Los Angeles

Gloved hands holding a glass jar of gray soil collected as an environmental sample

Counsel for Glendale and Los Angeles owners, buyers, and former operators on cleanup orders, CERCLA cost recovery and contribution, and pre-purchase diligence.

Who pays for an environmental cleanup in California?

Under CERCLA section 107(a), liability for response costs can reach the current owner or operator, anyone who owned or operated the site when hazardous substances were disposed of, parties who arranged for disposal, and certain transporters. Courts have generally treated that liability as strict. A party that pays more than its share may seek contribution from the others under section 113(f), where the court may allocate costs using equitable factors.

At a glance

Key deadline
Cost recovery: 3 years after removal; 6 years after remedial construction begins
Governing law
CERCLA §§ 107 and 113; Water Code § 13304; H&S Code § 78000
Forum / agency
Los Angeles Regional Water Board, DTSC, and EPA Region 9
Buyer diligence
All appropriate inquiries within one year before acquisition (40 C.F.R. § 312.20)

Environmental remediation law decides who must investigate and clean up contaminated soil or groundwater, and who ultimately pays, under the federal CERCLA statute and the California Water Code. DiJulio Law Group represents owners, buyers, landlords, and former operators in Glendale and Los Angeles through agency cleanup orders, cost recovery, and contribution claims.

Environmental cleanup liability and cost recovery in Los Angeles

A remediation matter usually starts with a finding: a Phase II sampling result during a sale, a leaking tank discovered during construction, or a letter from a regulator asking for a site investigation. From that point, two processes run at once. A lead agency oversees investigation and cleanup, and the parties connected to the property sort out who bears the cost. This page covers both; trustee claims for injury to public resources are covered under natural resource damages.

The two tracks do not wait for each other. On the regulatory track, an agency directs investigation and remediation on a schedule that does not pause for private disputes. On the private track, the parties allocate who pays, pursue contribution from others who contributed, and look for historical insurers. Managing both at the same time, rather than one after the other, is what controls total cost.

In Los Angeles County the lead agency is typically the Los Angeles Regional Water Quality Control Board (opens in a new tab) where groundwater is threatened, or the Department of Toxic Substances Control for many hazardous substance sites, with U.S. EPA involved at federal Superfund sites. The Regional Board may issue a cleanup and abatement order under Water Code section 13304 to a person who discharged waste, or caused or permitted it to be discharged, where it creates or threatens a condition of pollution or nuisance. California's state Superfund law, the Hazardous Substance Account Act, is now codified at Health and Safety Code section 78000 and following.

On the private side, CERCLA lets a party that incurs necessary response costs consistent with the National Contingency Plan recover them from other responsible parties, and lets a party that has been sued or has settled with the government seek contribution. Which route is available, and the deadline for it, depends on how the costs were incurred. Petroleum is generally excluded from CERCLA's definition of hazardous substance, so fuel releases are usually handled under state programs instead, which often shapes negotiations in commercial real estate transactions.

Cost recovery or contribution: which CERCLA claim fits your cleanup costs?

CERCLA §§ 107 and 113

It depends on how the costs were incurred. A party that paid for cleanup on its own generally sues for cost recovery under CERCLA section 107(a). A party that has been sued under section 106 or 107, or has settled with the United States or a State, seeks contribution under section 113(f). The deadlines differ.

The Supreme Court has drawn the line in two decisions. In Cooper Industries v. Aviall Services (2004), it held that a private party that has not been sued under section 106 or 107(a) may not obtain contribution under section 113(f)(1). In United States v. Atlantic Research Corp. (2007), it held that section 107(a) gives potentially responsible parties a cause of action to recover costs from other potentially responsible parties. The statute itself is at 42 U.S.C. § 9613 (opens in a new tab).

CERCLA cost recovery (§ 107) and contribution (§ 113) compared
QuestionCost recovery, § 107(a)Contribution, § 113(f)
Who brings itAny person that incurred necessary response costs consistent with the National Contingency PlanA person sued under § 106 or § 107(a), or one that resolved its liability to the United States or a State in an approved settlement
What is recoveredNecessary costs of response, plus interest from the later of a written demand or the expenditureAn equitable share; the court may allocate response costs using equitable factors it finds appropriate
DeadlineRemoval: 3 years after the removal action is completed. Remedial: 6 years after physical on-site construction begins (§ 113(g)(2))3 years after the judgment, or after a § 122(g) or § 122(h) order or a judicially approved settlement (§ 113(g)(3))
Effect of a settlementA party that settled with the government is protected from contribution claims on matters addressed in the settlement (§ 113(f)(2))The settlement reduces the other parties' potential liability by the amount of the settlement
DefensesLimited to those in § 107(b), such as act of God, act of war, or certain third-party acts, plus statutory purchaser protectionsThe same liability defenses, plus arguments about each party's equitable share
Rows of glass jars holding soil samples of different colors in a wooden crate
Cleanup obligations often turn on site history, sampling data, and how responsibility is shared among past and present owners.

How does a buyer limit contamination liability before closing?

Buyer Due Diligence

Mainly by qualifying as a bona fide prospective purchaser under CERCLA and by negotiating the purchase agreement. The federal protection requires that all disposal occurred before acquisition and that the buyer made all appropriate inquiries into prior ownership and uses, following EPA's rule at 40 C.F.R. Part 312 and the ASTM E1527-21 Phase I standard.

Under 40 C.F.R. Part 312 (opens in a new tab), all appropriate inquiries must be conducted within one year before the acquisition date, and several components must be conducted or updated within 180 days before acquisition. Section 312.11 recognizes ASTM E1527-21 for a Phase I; the older E1527-13 standard could be used only until February 13, 2024. A Phase I report that has gone stale by closing may not support the defense.

The protection, defined in CERCLA section 101(40) and applied by section 107(r), also carries continuing duties after closing. The purchaser must give legally required notices, take reasonable steps to stop continuing releases and limit exposure, cooperate with and provide access for response work, comply with land use restrictions, respond to EPA information requests, and not be affiliated with a liable party. Indemnities, escrow holdbacks, and access rights are negotiated alongside those duties in commercial real estate transactions.

Components that must be current within 180 days before acquisition (40 C.F.R. § 312.20(b))

  • Interviews with past and present owners, operators, and occupants.
  • Searches for recorded environmental cleanup liens.
  • Reviews of federal, tribal, state, and local government records.
  • Visual inspections of the facility and of adjoining properties.
  • The environmental professional's declaration.

Can a tenant be held liable for contamination at a leased property?

Landlords and Tenants

Yes, in many cases. A tenant that ran the operations that released hazardous substances may be treated as an operator under CERCLA section 107(a), and a Regional Board may order a person who caused or permitted a discharge to clean it up under Water Code section 13304. The landlord, as current owner, may be named as well.

The lease matters, but mostly between the parties. Under CERCLA section 107(e) (opens in a new tab), an indemnification or hold harmless agreement cannot transfer CERCLA liability away from a liable owner or operator, although the same provision allows agreements to insure, hold harmless, or indemnify a party to the agreement. An agency may therefore look to the owner, the tenant, or both, while the lease's environmental clauses generally decide who reimburses whom.

Landlords can reduce exposure with use restrictions, hazardous materials clauses, inspection and access rights, and move-out investigation obligations in the commercial lease. Tenants taking space previously used for industrial work may want a baseline assessment before moving in.

Paying for remediation: historical insurance, closure, and redevelopment

Insurance and Closure

Cleanup is usually paid from three sources: the parties who contributed, historical insurers, and the value a closed site regains. Old general liability policies from the operating period sometimes respond to contamination claims, and an agency closure with a recorded land use covenant can let a site be sold, financed, or redeveloped before unrestricted cleanup.

Insurance archaeology starts with the site history: who owned and operated the property, in which years, and through which entities. Broker files, old financial statements, and certificates of insurance can establish a policy even when the policy itself is lost. Notice should be given promptly once a claim or order arrives.

On the closure side, California agencies may approve closure with a recorded land use covenant under Civil Code section 1471 that restricts uses such as residential occupancy or groundwater extraction. A developer planning housing on a former industrial parcel usually needs that closure on a schedule the financing can support, which makes the agency negotiation part of the transaction timeline. Where government trustees also claim injury to groundwater or wildlife, see natural resource damages.

R. David DiJulio, Managing Partner, DiJulio Law GroupManaging PartnerR. David DiJulioRead profile
Office
330 North Brand Boulevard, Suite 1280, Glendale, California 91203
Courts
Los Angeles County Superior Court, including the Glendale and Stanley Mosk courthouses.
Focus
Enforcement defense, permitting and compliance, hazardous waste, and cleanup cost recovery in California.

Cleanup and cost recovery matters we handle

For owners, purchasers, lenders, landlords, tenants, and former operators of contaminated property across Los Angeles and Glendale.

Cleanup and Abatement Orders

Responding to Regional Board orders under Water Code section 13304 and DTSC oversight, including who is named, the scope of work, the schedule, and the path to a no-further-action determination.

CERCLA Cost Recovery

Section 107(a) claims to recover response costs from other responsible parties, including building the record needed to show the work was consistent with the National Contingency Plan.

Contribution and Allocation

Section 113(f) contribution claims and defenses, equitable allocation among current and former owners and operators, and mediated allocation of multi-party sites.

Insurance Recovery

Locating and pursuing historical general liability policies that may respond to contamination claims, including allocation across many policy periods.

Transaction Risk

Environmental indemnities, escrows, access agreements, and the pre-closing inquiry needed to preserve purchaser protections, coordinated with legal due diligence.

Closure and Land Use Covenants

Negotiating closure terms and recorded land use covenants that restrict future use so a site can be sold, financed, or redeveloped.

Cleanup and cost recovery disputes that reach our office

Composite examples of the matters this practice handles. They illustrate common fact patterns and are not descriptions of specific client cases or predictions of any result.

The Dry Cleaner Tenant

A Glendale retail center owner learns that solvent from a former dry cleaner tenant has reached groundwater. The owner faces a Regional Board order as the current owner, and the lease, the tenant's insurers, and the tenant's successors become the focus of cost recovery.

The Contamination Found in Escrow

A buyer's Phase II finds metals and solvents beneath a Los Angeles industrial building. Whether to close, and on what terms, turns on the indemnity, a price holdback, and whether the buyer can still qualify for purchaser protections.

The Purchaser Defense That Failed

A buyer who skipped a Phase I is later named as a responsible party. Without all appropriate inquiries made before acquisition, the bona fide prospective purchaser protection is generally unavailable, and the case turns to contribution from prior owners and operators.

First steps when contamination is found on a property

  1. Calendar the agency deadlines

    Orders and work plan requests carry their own schedules that do not pause for private disputes. Missing one can add enforcement exposure to the cleanup itself.

  2. Build the site history

    Ownership, leases, operations, and waste handling by period are the foundation of any cost recovery or contribution claim. Collect title records, leases, permits, and prior reports now.

  3. Search for old policies and document every cost

    Historical general liability policies sometimes respond to contamination claims, and even fragmentary evidence of coverage has value. Keep invoices, scopes of work, and agency approvals organized from the first day, and talk with counsel before signing any agreement with the agency.

Signs a contamination or cleanup matter needs counsel

  • A Regional Board or DTSC letter has requested investigation or a work plan.
  • You have received a cleanup and abatement order or a contribution demand from another party.
  • A Phase I or Phase II report has identified a recognized environmental condition.
  • You are paying for cleanup that others caused or contributed to.
  • You may hold historical insurance policies covering the operating period.
  • You need closure so a property can be sold, financed, or redeveloped.

CERCLA, all appropriate inquiries, and California cleanup law

Cleanup and cost recovery questions California owners and buyers ask

What owners, buyers, tenants, and former operators ask about contaminated property and cleanup costs in California.

What is a potentially responsible party under CERCLA?

A potentially responsible party is anyone who falls within one of the four liability classes in CERCLA section 107(a): the current owner or operator of the facility, an owner or operator at the time hazardous substances were disposed of, a person who arranged for disposal or treatment, and a transporter who selected the disposal site. Being a potentially responsible party does not fix a share of cost; allocation among parties is decided separately.

Can I be liable for contamination I did not cause?

Yes, in many cases, because CERCLA liability attaches to the current owner of contaminated property even when the contamination came from a prior owner or a tenant, and courts have generally treated that liability as strict, so the question is usually which defense or protection applies and who else can be made to share the cost. The bona fide prospective purchaser and innocent landowner protections generally require all appropriate inquiries before acquisition.

What is the difference between CERCLA cost recovery and contribution?

Cost recovery under CERCLA section 107(a) lets a party that incurred necessary response costs consistent with the National Contingency Plan recover them from responsible parties, while contribution under section 113(f) is available to a party that has been sued under sections 106 or 107 or has resolved its liability to the United States or a State in an approved settlement. The two claims have different deadlines, so choosing the right route matters.

How long do I have to file a CERCLA cost recovery or contribution claim?

Under 42 U.S.C. § 9613(g), an initial cost recovery action generally must be filed within three years after a removal action is completed, or within six years after physical on-site construction of a remedial action begins, and a contribution action generally must be filed within three years after the relevant judgment or approved settlement. Which clock applies depends on the facts, so it should be analyzed early.

What is a Phase I environmental site assessment?

A Phase I environmental site assessment is a non-invasive review of a property's history, records, and condition, performed by an environmental professional to identify recognized environmental conditions, and EPA's all appropriate inquiries rule at 40 C.F.R. § 312.11 recognizes the ASTM E1527-21 standard for conducting one. It is the usual first step toward purchaser protections under CERCLA, and a Phase II with sampling follows when the Phase I finds a concern.

How are cleanup costs divided among several responsible parties?

In a contribution action under CERCLA section 113(f)(1), the court may allocate response costs among liable parties using whatever equitable factors it finds appropriate, which in practice often includes how much waste each party contributed, how toxic it was, and how involved each party was in operations and disposal decisions. Many multi-party sites are allocated by negotiation or mediation instead of trial.

Does CERCLA cover gasoline and diesel fuel leaks?

Generally not, because CERCLA's definition of hazardous substance excludes petroleum, including crude oil and its fractions, unless a component is separately listed, so releases from gasoline and diesel tanks are usually handled under California's underground storage tank and Water Board cleanup programs rather than through a federal CERCLA cost recovery claim. A site with both fuel and solvent contamination may involve both regimes at once.

How does remediation differ from natural resource damages?

Remediation addresses response costs, meaning the investigation and cleanup of contamination under agency oversight and the allocation of those costs among responsible parties, while natural resource damages are a separate claim that only designated government trustees may bring for injury to public resources such as groundwater, fish, and wildlife. The same release can give rise to both, and a cleanup settlement does not automatically resolve the trustees' claim.

Environmental cleanup and cost recovery in Glendale and Los Angeles

Cleanup sites in Glendale and across Los Angeles are overseen by the Los Angeles Regional Water Quality Control Board, DTSC, and, at federal Superfund sites, U.S. EPA. See the firm's environmental law practice for related matters.

Talk to an Environmental Attorney

Early decisions about who responds to the agency, and how costs are documented, shape every later recovery claim. Bring the order and the site history, and see hazardous waste compliance if ongoing operations are also involved.

Request a consultation(818) 502-1700

330 North Brand Boulevard, Suite 1280, Glendale, CA 91203