General Liability

Injury & Liability Litigation

General Liability Defense AttorneyFor California Businesses

Yellow wet floor caution sign on a glossy tiled floor in a public building

Defense of premises, negligence, and property damage claims, with insurer notice, tender, coverage, and indemnity handled from the first week.

What should a business do when it receives a liability claim?

Notify every potentially applicable insurer immediately, tender to any party that owes contractual indemnity or additional insured coverage, preserve all relevant evidence including video and maintenance records, and avoid recorded statements or admissions before counsel reviews the file. Late notice is one of the most common reasons coverage is limited or denied.

At a glance

Duty to defend
Insurer must defend suits potentially within coverage (Gray v. Zurich, 1966)
Independent counsel
Civ. Code § 2860 when a reservation of rights creates a conflict
Indemnity limits
Civ. Code §§ 2782 and 2782.05 limit construction indemnity
We represent
Businesses, property owners, managers, and contractors

A general liability claim alleges that a business or property owner caused injury or damage through a failure to use ordinary care, the negligence standard in Civil Code section 1714. DiJulio Law Group defends businesses and property owners in Glendale and Los Angeles, including insurer notice, tender to indemnitors, and evidence preservation in the first weeks.

General liability defense attorney for California businesses

A general liability claim usually arrives as an incident report or a demand letter, and the immediate questions are the same regardless of the underlying facts: which policies respond, who else owes indemnity or additional insured coverage, and what evidence needs to be preserved before it disappears. Businesses that handle those three items well in the first weeks typically face a manageable claim; businesses that do not often face a claim plus a coverage dispute.

Contractual risk transfer is where many outcomes are decided. Leases, service agreements, and construction contracts routinely allocate liability through indemnity clauses and additional insured requirements, and the effectiveness of those provisions depends on how they were drafted and whether the endorsements were actually obtained. California limits some indemnity provisions, particularly in construction, which affects whether the transfer works as intended.

Where a claim proceeds, the merits turn on duty, notice of the condition, causation, and comparative fault, the same framework applied in injury claims. Where the claim arises from a product, product liability rules apply instead, and where it arises on a construction project, construction litigation and its tender structure govern.

Liability claims often overlap with other practice areas. Injuries on a construction site can involve construction defect claims and contractual indemnity; injuries on leased property raise questions under the lease and the owner's obligations under real estate law. Businesses defending claims should review insurance and indemnity terms in their commercial contracts, and many liability disputes resolve through mediation. Contact the firm to discuss a claim.

How tender and insurance coverage work after a liability claim

Tender and coverage

When a claim arrives, the business notifies every potentially responsive insurer, tenders its defense in writing, and the insurer decides whether to defend. California insurers must defend suits that potentially seek covered damages (Gray v. Zurich, 1966). A reservation of rights can trigger independent counsel under Civil Code section 2860, and contractual indemnity runs on a parallel track.

The duty to defend turns on the facts known to the insurer when the lawsuit begins, not on how coverage is finally decided. Under Civil Code section 2860 (opens in a new tab), no conflict exists as to allegations for which the insurer denies coverage outright, or solely because punitive damages are claimed or the suit exceeds policy limits. The insurer may require independent counsel to have at least five years of civil litigation practice with substantial defense experience and errors and omissions coverage, and it pays only the rates it actually pays its own defense counsel for similar cases in that community.

Additional insured endorsement requirements are excluded from the section 2782.05 limits, so a properly endorsed policy can still respond where a contractual indemnity clause cannot. Construction-site claims also involve the tender rules discussed under construction litigation.

Tender and coverage, step by step
  1. Day 1

    Notice to every carrier

    Report the incident or claim to every general liability, umbrella, and other policy that might respond, even where coverage seems unlikely.

  2. First week

    Tender of defense

    Send the complaint or demand to the insurer and ask in writing that it defend. Attach the policy information and the claim documents.

  3. On tender

    Duty to defend

    The insurer must defend a suit that potentially seeks covered damages (Gray v. Zurich Insurance Co. (1966) 65 Cal.2d 263). The insured need only show the claim may fall within coverage; the insurer must prove it cannot (Montrose Chemical Corp. v. Superior Court (1993) 6 Cal.4th 287).

  4. If rights are reserved

    Reservation of rights and independent counsel

    When the outcome of a reserved coverage issue can be controlled by the defense lawyer the insurer chose, a conflict may exist, and the insurer must provide independent counsel unless the insured waives it in writing (Civ. Code § 2860).

  5. In parallel

    Additional insured tender

    Tender to every vendor, tenant, or contractor whose contract required it to name your business as an additional insured, attaching the contract clause and the endorsement.

  6. When indemnity is tested

    Indemnity limits

    Construction indemnity for a party's sole negligence or willful misconduct is void (Civ. Code § 2782), and most commercial subcontract indemnity cannot reach the indemnitee's active negligence (§ 2782.05).

Single story commercial building beside a wet parking lot on an overcast day
Property owners and businesses owe visitors reasonable care, and insurance coverage often shapes how these claims are resolved.

What to do in the first 30 days after a liability claim

First 30 days

The first 30 days decide whether a liability claim stays a defense problem or turns into a coverage dispute as well. In that window, notify every carrier, tender to every indemnitor and additional insured carrier in writing, lock down video and records, route all communications through one person, and calendar every response date the complaint or contract sets.

For commercial construction contracts entered into on or after January 1, 2013, a subcontractor that receives a written tender under Civil Code section 2782.05 (opens in a new tab) must elect either to defend with counsel of its choice, giving written notice within a reasonable time and no later than 30 days, or to pay a reasonable allocated share of defense fees within 30 days of each invoice. Residential construction under section 2782 allows up to 90 days for the election.

First 30 days after a claim

  • Report the claim to every insurer that might respond and save proof of each notice
  • Pull every lease, service agreement, and subcontract with indemnity or additional insured terms
  • Tender in writing to each indemnitor and additional insured carrier, attaching the contract language
  • Preserve video, incident reports, inspection and maintenance logs, and witness contact information
  • Name one person to receive all claim correspondence and stop informal statements to the claimant
  • Calendar the response date on any summons; a written response is generally due within 30 days of service (CCP § 412.20)
  • Read any reservation of rights letter for a conflict that triggers Civil Code section 2860
  • If a construction subcontractor receives your tender, track its election deadline under section 2782.05
R. David DiJulio, Managing Partner, DiJulio Law GroupManaging PartnerR. David DiJulioRead profile
Office
330 North Brand Boulevard, Suite 1280, Glendale, California 91203
Courts
Los Angeles County Superior Court, including the Glendale and Stanley Mosk courthouses.
Focus
Injury claims, product defect litigation, and liability defense in the Los Angeles County courts.

General liability defense matters we handle

For businesses, property owners, managers, and contractors across Los Angeles County.

Premises Claims

Defense of slip and fall, dangerous condition, and inadequate security claims, focused on notice, inspection practice, and causation.

Property Damage Claims

Water intrusion between units, fire and casualty, and damage to neighboring property, including subrogation defense.

Tender & Risk Transfer

Tendering to indemnitors and additional insured carriers, and enforcing the transfer where a tender is refused.

Coverage Coordination

Working with carriers on defense, reservations of rights, and independent counsel questions where a conflict arises.

Contractual Indemnity

Enforcing and defending indemnity provisions in leases, service agreements, and construction contracts within California's statutory limits.

Pre-Claim Risk Review

Contract and insurance review that ensures indemnity and additional insured requirements actually function when a claim arrives.

General liability claim scenarios in Los Angeles County

Composite examples of the matters this practice handles. They illustrate common fact patterns and are not descriptions of specific client cases or predictions of any result.

The Vendor Who Was Never Endorsed

A service contract required additional insured status, but the certificate was never backed by an actual endorsement. When a claim arrives, the intended risk transfer does not exist.

The Late Notice

A property manager handles an incident internally for months before notifying the carrier. The delay becomes a coverage issue layered on top of the underlying claim.

The Water That Crossed the Wall

A leak in one commercial unit damages inventory in the adjoining space. Responsibility depends on the lease, the building systems involved, and which policies respond first.

First steps when a liability claim reaches your business

  1. Notice every carrier

    Late notice is a leading cause of coverage disputes. Notify all potentially applicable policies promptly, even where coverage seems unlikely.

  2. Tender contractually

    Identify every party that owes indemnity or additional insured coverage and tender in writing, attaching the contract language relied on.

  3. Preserve and document

    Video, incident reports, inspection logs, and witness information disappear quickly. Preserve them before responding substantively.

Signs a business liability claim needs defense counsel

  • An incident has occurred on your premises or during your operations.
  • You have received a demand letter, claim, or lawsuit.
  • An insurer has reserved rights or denied coverage.
  • A tender to a vendor, tenant, or contractor has been refused.
  • Evidence such as video or maintenance records needs to be preserved.
  • Certificates of insurance were collected but endorsements were never verified.

California duty to defend and indemnity statutes

General liability defense questions California businesses ask

What California businesses and property owners ask when a liability claim arrives.

What should a business do first when it receives a liability claim?

When a liability claim arrives, a business should notify every insurer whose policy might respond, tender the claim in writing to any vendor, tenant, or contractor that owes indemnity or additional insured coverage, preserve video, logs, and incident reports, and avoid recorded statements or admissions until counsel has reviewed the file. Late notice is a common source of coverage disputes that are harder to resolve than the claim itself.

When does an insurer have to defend my business?

Under Gray v. Zurich Insurance Co. (1966) and Montrose Chemical Corp. v. Superior Court (1993), a liability insurer must defend a suit that potentially seeks damages within the policy's coverage, and the insured need only show that the claim may fall within coverage, while the insurer must prove that it cannot. The duty to defend turns on the facts known to the insurer when the lawsuit begins, not on the final coverage outcome.

What is a reservation of rights letter?

A reservation of rights letter is an insurer's notice that it will defend the claim for now while keeping the right to deny coverage later on stated grounds, and under Civil Code section 2860, when the outcome of a reserved coverage issue can be controlled by the defense lawyer the insurer chose, a conflict of interest may exist. Where that conflict exists, the insurer must provide independent counsel unless the insured waives it in writing.

What is Cumis counsel?

Cumis counsel is the common name for the independent counsel that Civil Code section 2860 requires an insurer to provide when a conflict of interest arises, typically because the insurer reserved rights on an issue its appointed lawyer could influence, and the insurer may require that counsel to have at least five years of civil litigation practice. The insurer may also require errors and omissions coverage, pays only the rates it actually pays its own defense counsel for similar cases, and fee disputes go to binding arbitration.

What is an additional insured tender?

An additional insured tender is a written request that another company's liability insurer defend and indemnify your business as an additional insured under that company's policy, usually because a lease, service agreement, or subcontract required the other party to add you by endorsement, and it should attach both the contract clause and the endorsement itself. A certificate of insurance alone may not prove the endorsement was ever issued.

Does California limit indemnity clauses in construction contracts?

Yes, Civil Code section 2782 voids construction contract clauses that would indemnify a party for its own sole negligence or willful misconduct, and for most commercial subcontracts entered into on or after January 1, 2013, section 2782.05 makes indemnity from a subcontractor unenforceable to the extent the claim arises from the indemnitee's active negligence. It also cannot reach claims outside the subcontractor's scope of work, and separate rules apply to public agencies, private owners, and residential construction.

How fast must a subcontractor respond to a tender of defense?

For commercial construction contracts covered by Civil Code section 2782.05, a subcontractor that receives a written tender must either elect to defend with counsel of its choice, giving written notice within a reasonable time and no later than 30 days, or pay a reasonable allocated share of the defense fees within 30 days of receiving each invoice. Residential construction contracts under section 2782 allow up to 90 days for the election.

Is general liability defense different from personal injury representation?

General liability defense protects the business, property owner, or contractor accused of causing injury or property damage, and it combines the merits defense of duty, notice, causation, and comparative fault with the insurance and contract work of tender, coverage, and indemnity that a claimant's lawyer never has to handle. Personal injury representation, by contrast, pursues compensation for the person who was hurt.

General liability defense in Glendale and Los Angeles

Liability claims arising in Glendale and Los Angeles are litigated in the Los Angeles County Superior Court.

Talk to a Litigation Attorney

Notice, tender, and preservation are the three decisions that cannot be made late. Bring the claim and your policies.

Request a consultation(818) 502-1700

330 North Brand Boulevard, Suite 1280, Glendale, CA 91203