Environmental Mediation AttorneyGlendale & Los Angeles

Mediation of contamination cost allocation among current and former owners, operators, tenants, and insurers, coordinated with the agency cleanup schedule.
Why is mediation used in environmental cost allocation disputes?
Because liability is typically shared among current and former owners, operators, tenants, and insurers, and the technical proof needed to allocate it precisely is expensive and rarely conclusive. Mediation allows the parties to negotiate cost shares, sequencing, and future contingencies while cleanup proceeds, rather than deferring every decision until a court rules years later.
At a glance
- Contribution law
- CERCLA § 113(f)(1): courts allocate costs by equitable factors
- Key deadline
- Contribution suit within 3 years of judgment or approved settlement
- Orphan shares
- Shares of insolvent or defunct parties; EPA may forgo some
- We represent
- Owners, former operators, tenants, and buyers of affected sites
Environmental mediation allocates cleanup costs among current and former owners, operators, tenants, and insurers, whose shared liability often arises under CERCLA and California law and who may seek contribution from one another. DiJulio Law Group represents parties in mediating contamination and cost allocation disputes involving sites in Los Angeles and Glendale.
Environmental mediation for Los Angeles contamination disputes
Contamination liability in California attaches broadly and reaches back in time. A current owner may face cleanup obligations for conditions created decades earlier by a former operator, and a former operator may face contribution claims long after selling. Dry cleaners, plating shops, auto and equipment service, and fueling operations generate a disproportionate share of these disputes in Los Angeles County.
Litigating allocation is slow and expert-heavy. Establishing precisely which operator contributed which share of a plume, over what period, requires technical work that can rival the cleanup cost itself. Mediation lets the parties negotiate cost shares directly and, importantly, address the questions litigation handles poorly: who manages the work, how future discoveries are treated, and how insurance recoveries are shared.
Regulatory obligations continue while the private dispute is mediated, which shapes the timetable. Coordinating a negotiated allocation with the agency compliance track and the remediation schedule is central to the work, and it frequently arises in property transactions where a deal depends on resolving legacy contamination.
Environmental mediations are organized around a technical record. Cleanup allocation disputes connect to environmental remediation and cost recovery, agency matters to environmental enforcement, and trustee claims to natural resource damages. Permit and discharge disputes draw on the firm's work under the Clean Water Act and Clean Air Act, and on hazardous waste rules. The full practice is described on the environmental law page.
Environmental mediation vs. arbitration vs. a CERCLA contribution suit
Mediation · Arbitration · Litigation
Parties sharing a cleanup bill can negotiate shares in mediation, submit them to a private allocator or arbitrator, or sue for contribution under CERCLA section 113(f). Mediation is usually fastest and cheapest, but only a settlement with the United States or a State that is administratively or judicially approved carries statutory protection from other parties' contribution claims.
| Question | Mediation | Arbitration or private allocation | CERCLA contribution suit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who sets the shares? | The parties, with a mediator. | A neutral the parties choose, under rules they agree on. | A federal court, using equitable factors it considers appropriate (§ 113(f)(1)). |
| Who is bound? | Only the parties who sign. | Only the parties to the arbitration agreement. | The parties to the case. |
| Protection from other parties' claims | None by statute for a purely private deal; address it in the agreement. | None by statute. | A party that settles with the United States or a State in an approved settlement is protected (§ 113(f)(2)). |
| Timing | Can run while cleanup proceeds. | Set by the agreement. | Contribution suits must be filed within 3 years of a qualifying judgment or settlement (§ 113(g)(3)). |

How multiple responsible parties split environmental cleanup costs
CERCLA § 113(f)
Under CERCLA section 113(f)(1), a liable or potentially liable party may seek contribution from others, and a court may allocate response costs using whatever equitable factors it finds appropriate. The Ninth Circuit approves starting from the six Gore factors. Mediated allocations use the same factors, plus a negotiated method for orphan shares and future costs.
The Gore factors, as the Ninth Circuit listed them in TDY Holdings v. United States (opens in a new tab) (2018), are: whether a party can show its contribution to the release can be distinguished; the amount of hazardous waste involved; its toxicity; the party's involvement in generating, transporting, treating, storing, or disposing of it; the care the party exercised; and the party's cooperation with federal, state, or local officials. The same opinion stresses that district courts have broad discretion in allocating costs among responsible parties.
An orphan share is the part of the cleanup attributable to insolvent or defunct parties. Because Superfund liability is joint and several, the government can require the solvent parties to cover it, although EPA's orphan share compensation policy (opens in a new tab) allows it to forgo some or all of that share for parties that sign a cleanup agreement. In a private mediation the orphan share is simply one more number to divide.
Volumetric
Shares track each party's estimated volume of the contaminant, often weighted for toxicity. Works best where records of use or disposal exist.
Operational period
Shares track the years each owner or tenant ran the operation that caused the release. Common for dry cleaners, plating shops, and fueling sites.
Orphan share handling
The parties agree whether the orphan share is spread pro rata, absorbed by the owner, or funded from insurance recoveries.
Future costs and reopeners
The agreement sets how new contamination, agency-required extra work, and cost overruns are shared after signing.
Managing PartnerR. David DiJulioRead profile- Office
- 330 North Brand Boulevard, Suite 1280, Glendale, California 91203
- Direct line
- (818) 502-1700 · rdd@dijuliolaw.com
- Courts
- Los Angeles County Superior Court, including the Glendale and Stanley Mosk courthouses.
- Focus
- Private mediation of business, real estate, construction, and environmental disputes in Southern California.
Environmental disputes we mediate in Southern California
Multi-party allocation and project disputes across California.
Cost Allocation
Dividing investigation and cleanup costs among current and former owners, operators, and tenants based on operational history and contribution.
Owner-Tenant Disputes
Responsibility for conditions arising from a tenant's operations, indemnity under the lease, and surrender and restoration obligations.
Insurance Recovery
Allocation of recoveries under historical general liability policies, including coverage across multiple policy periods and carriers.
Transaction Disputes
Contamination discovered during or after a sale, and disputes over representations, indemnities, and environmental holdbacks.
Regulatory Sequencing
Coordinating a negotiated allocation with agency deadlines so that private disputes do not delay required work.
Project & Land Use Conflicts
Disputes among developers, neighbors, and agencies over project impacts, mitigation, and conditions of approval.
Environmental mediation scenarios in Los Angeles County
Composite examples of the matters this practice handles. They illustrate common fact patterns and are not descriptions of specific client cases or predictions of any result.
The Legacy Dry Cleaner
Solvent contamination is identified beneath a Los Angeles retail property operated by three successive tenants over thirty years. Allocating responsibility by operational period through mediation avoids years of expert litigation over the same records.
The Deal That Stalled
A property sale halts when Phase II results show impacted soil. Mediation among buyer, seller, and the former operator produces an escrow, an indemnity, and a work plan that allows closing to proceed.
The Historical Policies
An owner locates general liability policies from the 1970s and 1980s. Multiple carriers dispute allocation across policy periods. Mediation resolves the split faster than sequential coverage litigation.
First steps in an environmental cost allocation mediation
Build the site history
Ownership, tenancy, and operational history by period is the foundation of every allocation argument. Assemble it before mediation.
Locate historical policies
Old general liability policies frequently respond to contamination claims. Even partial evidence of coverage can materially change allocation.
Separate the tracks
Agency obligations do not pause for private disputes. Keep required work moving while allocation is negotiated.
When environmental mediation fits a cleanup dispute
- Multiple parties contributed to a condition over different periods.
- Cleanup costs are substantial and allocation is disputed.
- A transaction is blocked by unresolved contamination responsibility.
- Historical insurance policies may respond and carriers disagree on allocation.
- A regulatory deadline is running while the private dispute is unresolved.
- Expert costs to litigate allocation approach the cleanup cost itself.
CERCLA allocation law and EPA settlement policy
- 42 U.S.C. § 9613: CERCLA Contribution and Settlement (opens in a new tab)Authorizes contribution claims, sets equitable allocation, protects approved settlements, and sets the 3-year contribution deadline.
- U.S. EPA: Incentives for Negotiating Superfund Settlements (opens in a new tab)EPA's explanation of orphan shares and its orphan share compensation policy for settling parties.
- Ninth Circuit: TDY Holdings v. United States (2018) (opens in a new tab)Lists the Gore factors and confirms district courts' broad discretion in allocating CERCLA cleanup costs.
Environmental mediation cases we’ve analyzed
Court decisions and legal developments DiJulio Law Group has written about. Each summary explains the law; none describes a firm client or result.
Environmental mediation questions owners and operators ask
What owners, operators, and insurers ask about mediating California environmental cost disputes.
What is environmental mediation?
Environmental mediation is a confidential, mediator-led negotiation in which current and former owners, operators, tenants, and sometimes insurers try to agree on who pays for investigating and cleaning up contamination, how the work will be managed, and how future costs, new discoveries, and insurance recoveries will be shared among them. It runs alongside, not instead of, the agency's cleanup requirements.
How do courts split cleanup costs among responsible parties under CERCLA?
Under CERCLA section 113(f)(1), a party that is liable or potentially liable may seek contribution from others, and in resolving those claims a federal court may allocate response costs among liable parties using whatever equitable factors it determines are appropriate, which gives judges broad discretion and makes the outcome of a contested allocation hard to predict. Many courts, including the Ninth Circuit, start from the six Gore factors.
What are the Gore factors?
The Gore factors are six equitable considerations many federal courts use in CERCLA allocation: whether a party's contribution can be distinguished, the amount of waste, its toxicity, the party's involvement in generating, transporting, treating, storing, or disposing of it, the care the party exercised, and its cooperation with government officials. The Ninth Circuit listed them in TDY Holdings v. United States (2018).
What is an orphan share in a contaminated site cleanup?
An orphan share is the portion of cleanup liability attributable to parties that are insolvent or defunct, and because Superfund liability is joint and several, the government can require the solvent responsible parties to pay that share too, which makes deciding who absorbs it one of the hardest issues in any allocation negotiation. EPA's orphan share compensation policy allows EPA to forgo some or all of the orphan share for parties that sign a cleanup agreement.
Does a mediated settlement protect us from contribution claims by other parties?
Not automatically, because CERCLA section 113(f)(2) gives contribution protection to a party that resolves its liability to the United States or a State in an administrative or judicially approved settlement, so a purely private mediated agreement binds only its signers and should spell out how claims by non-settling parties will be handled. An approved government settlement also reduces the others' potential liability by the settlement amount.
How long do we have to bring a CERCLA contribution claim?
CERCLA section 113(g)(3) bars a contribution action filed more than three years after the date of a judgment in an action for recovery of those costs, or after certain administrative de minimis or cost recovery settlement orders, or after entry of a judicially approved settlement covering those costs, so the clock can start before private negotiations are finished. Tolling agreements are often used to keep claims alive while parties mediate.
Does cleanup stop while environmental cost allocation is mediated?
No, agency deadlines for investigation and cleanup generally keep running while the private parties negotiate, so most environmental mediations work on two tracks at once, keeping required work moving under an interim cost-sharing arrangement while the final percentages, reallocation rights, and treatment of future costs are worked out at the table. Keeping the tracks separate avoids enforcement problems and protects the allocation.
What information do we need before an environmental mediation?
Before an environmental mediation, each party should assemble the ownership and tenancy history of the site by period, operational and chemical-use records, environmental reports and agency correspondence, cleanup cost records, and every general liability policy that may have been in force, because allocation arguments are built from those records rather than from positions. Even partial evidence of historical coverage can change the allocation.
Environmental mediation in Glendale and Los Angeles
Los Angeles County sites are overseen by state and regional agencies, and private allocation disputes are litigated in the county and federal courts.
Talk to a Mediator
Environmental allocation disputes get more expensive the longer they run, largely through expert cost. Early mediation is usually the economic choice.