Products Liability

Injury & Liability Litigation

Product Liability AttorneyLos Angeles & Glendale

White electric kettle with its power cord and plug, an everyday household appliance

Design, manufacturing, and failure-to-warn claims for injured people, and tender and indemnity defense for retailers and distributors.

What are the types of product defect claims in California?

California recognizes three theories: manufacturing defect, where a product departs from its intended design; design defect, evaluated under the consumer expectations test or the risk-benefit test; and failure to warn, where a foreseeable risk was known or knowable and not adequately disclosed. Strict liability applies to manufacturers, distributors, and retailers in the chain of distribution.

At a glance

Who is liable
Manufacturers, distributors, and retailers in the chain (Soule v. GM)
Design defect tests
Consumer expectations or risk-benefit (Barker v. Lull Engineering, 1978)
Injury deadline
Two years for personal injury suits (CCP § 335.1)
We represent
Injured people and businesses in the chain of distribution

Product liability holds manufacturers, distributors, and retailers responsible for injuries caused by manufacturing defects, design defects, or inadequate warnings, under the strict liability doctrine the California Supreme Court adopted in 1963. DiJulio Law Group represents injured parties and businesses in the chain of distribution in product claims in Glendale and Los Angeles.

Product liability attorney for Los Angeles and Glendale cases

California strict product liability reaches the entire commercial chain. A distributor or retailer that merely sold a sealed product can be named alongside the manufacturer, and the practical resolution usually runs through indemnity, additional insured status, and tender to upstream parties. For a downstream defendant, the first weeks are about getting out or getting defended, not about the merits of the defect.

Design defect claims are evaluated under two alternative tests. The consumer expectations test asks whether the product performed as safely as an ordinary consumer would expect. The risk-benefit test shifts the burden to the defendant to show that the design's benefits outweigh its risks, weighing feasible alternative designs. Which test applies depends on the product's complexity and is frequently disputed before it is tried.

Failure to warn claims are the most common and often the most difficult to defend, since they turn on what was known or knowable at the time of distribution and whether the warning given was adequate for the foreseeable user. These claims overlap with general liability exposure and with supply agreement indemnity terms negotiated long before the incident.

Product claims reach into several related areas. Businesses importing or manufacturing goods should address warranty, indemnity, and supplier terms in commercial contracts, particularly when sourcing overseas; see doing business in China. Defective building materials can give rise to construction defect claims, and product disputes between businesses are often resolved as breach of contract matters or through mediation. Companies weighing an acquisition should review product exposure in legal due diligence.

Product cases rarely stand alone. The injured person's side follows the same deadlines and evidence rules covered on our personal injury page, and a seller facing a product suit usually needs the tender, coverage, and indemnity work described under general liability defense.

Product defect theories in California: manufacturing, design, and warning

Theories table

California recognizes three product defect theories. A manufacturing defect means the unit differs from the intended design. A design defect is proved by the consumer expectations test or the risk-benefit test from Barker v. Lull Engineering Co. (1978) 20 Cal.3d 413. A failure-to-warn claim targets risks that were known or knowable but not adequately disclosed.

The two design tests are alternatives, and both may be presented in the same case. In Barker the California Supreme Court explained that once the plaintiff shows the design proximately caused the injury, the manufacturer bears the burden of persuading the jury that the design's benefits outweigh its risks. The elements of each claim are published in the Judicial Council's civil jury instructions (CACI) (opens in a new tab).

California product liability theories at a glance
TheoryWhat must be shownTest or authorityTypical evidence
Manufacturing defectThe product contained a manufacturing defect when it left the defendant's possession and the defect was a substantial factor in the harm.CACI No. 1201: the unit differs from the manufacturer's intended result or from other units of the same line.The failed unit, production and quality records, comparison units.
Design defect: consumer expectationsThe product did not perform as safely as an ordinary consumer would expect in intended or reasonably foreseeable use.Barker; CACI No. 1203. Reserved for products whose everyday use lets jurors form minimum safety expectations (Soule).How the product failed and the circumstances of use; expert opinion on consumer expectations is generally improper.
Design defect: risk-benefitThe design caused the injury; the burden then shifts to the defendant to prove the benefits outweigh the risks.Barker; CACI No. 1204 factors: gravity and likelihood of harm, feasibility, cost, and disadvantages of a safer alternative design.Engineering analysis, alternative designs, industry history.
Failure to warnRisks known or knowable under generally accepted scientific knowledge, a substantial danger in foreseeable use, not obvious to ordinary consumers, and inadequate warnings.CACI No. 1205.Labels, manuals, prior complaints, testing and literature available at the time of sale.
Old wooden ladder with broken rungs lying in dry grass and rubble
Product liability claims can rest on a design defect, a manufacturing defect, or missing warnings and instructions.

How to preserve evidence in a Los Angeles product liability case

Evidence preservation

The product itself is usually the most important evidence in the case. Keep it unaltered with its packaging, labels, manuals, receipts, and any broken pieces, photograph everything, log who handles it, and do not allow any testing or disassembly until every interested party has been notified and can attend.

A jury may infer that intentionally concealed or destroyed evidence would have been unfavorable to the party responsible (CACI No. 204 (opens in a new tab)). Unlimited civil product liability injury cases in Los Angeles County, other than asbestos and toxic or environmental cases, are filed at the Stanley Mosk Courthouse or the Antelope Valley Courthouse under Local Rule 2.3.

Product evidence preservation checklist

  • Store the product as it was after the incident: do not clean, repair, or reassemble it
  • Keep packaging, labels, warnings, manuals, receipts, and serial or lot numbers
  • Photograph and video the product and the scene from every side, with a scale reference
  • Record a chain of custody: who has held the item, when, and where it was stored
  • Send written preservation notices to the manufacturer, seller, and any insurer
  • Hold off on destructive testing until all parties have notice and a chance to attend
  • Save online listings, recall notices, and any prior complaints about the same model
R. David DiJulio, Managing Partner, DiJulio Law GroupManaging PartnerR. David DiJulioRead profile
Office
330 North Brand Boulevard, Suite 1280, Glendale, California 91203
Courts
Los Angeles County Superior Court, including the Glendale and Stanley Mosk courthouses.
Focus
Injury claims, product defect litigation, and liability defense in the Los Angeles County courts.

Product liability matters we handle in Los Angeles

For injured claimants and for manufacturers, distributors, and retailers in the California chain of distribution.

Design Defect Claims

Consumer expectations and risk-benefit analysis, feasible alternative designs, and the expert proof each test requires.

Manufacturing Defect Claims

Departure from intended design, quality control and process evidence, and identifying the point of failure in production.

Failure to Warn

Adequacy of warnings and instructions, foreseeable misuse, the sophisticated user doctrine, and state-of-the-art evidence.

Retailer & Distributor Defense

Tender to manufacturers and upstream suppliers, indemnity and additional insured claims, and early dismissal where available.

Recall & Regulatory Issues

Reporting obligations, recall coordination, and the evidentiary treatment of subsequent remedial measures.

Supply Chain Indemnity

Enforcing indemnity, insurance, and defense obligations under distribution and supply agreements, including cross-border suppliers.

Product liability scenarios in Los Angeles County

Composite examples of the matters this practice handles. They illustrate common fact patterns and are not descriptions of specific client cases or predictions of any result.

The Retailer in the Middle

A Glendale retailer is named in a suit over a product it sold sealed and never modified. The defense strategy is tender and indemnity against the manufacturer and importer, pursued immediately rather than after discovery.

The Missing Product

The allegedly defective item was discarded after the incident. Both sides face proof problems, and the spoliation issue frequently becomes as significant as the defect analysis.

The Overseas Manufacturer

The manufacturer is offshore with no U.S. presence and no meaningful insurance. Exposure concentrates on the importer and distributor, and the indemnity terms in the supply agreement decide the outcome.

First steps after a product injury or product claim

  1. Preserve the product

    The item, its packaging, warnings, and any remnants are the central evidence. Keep them unaltered and document who handles them.

  2. Tender immediately

    Sellers and distributors should tender to upstream suppliers and insurers as soon as a claim appears. Late tender can jeopardize indemnity and coverage.

  3. Track the two-year deadline

    Injury claims generally must be filed within two years (CCP § 335.1), and identifying every company in the chain takes time.

When a product claim needs a Los Angeles attorney

  • A product failure has caused injury or significant property damage.
  • You have been named in a suit over a product you sold or distributed.
  • An upstream supplier has refused a tender of defense.
  • A regulator or the CPSC has made an inquiry about your product.
  • A recall is being considered or has been announced.
  • The product itself may be discarded or altered before it can be examined.

California product liability jury instructions and statutes

Product liability questions Los Angeles clients ask

What claimants, retailers, and manufacturers ask about California product liability exposure.

What are the three types of product defect claims in California?

California recognizes three main product liability theories: a manufacturing defect, where the product differs from the manufacturer's design or from other units in the line; a design defect, proved under the consumer expectations test or the risk-benefit test; and a failure to warn about risks that were known or knowable when the product was made or sold. The elements appear in the Judicial Council's CACI instructions 1201 through 1205.

What is the consumer expectations test?

Under the consumer expectations test from Barker v. Lull Engineering Co. (1978), a product's design is defective if the product failed to perform as safely as an ordinary consumer would expect when used in an intended or reasonably foreseeable manner, a test reserved for products whose everyday use lets jurors form minimum safety expectations. The California Supreme Court limited the test that way in Soule v. General Motors Corp. (1994).

What is the risk-benefit test for design defect?

Under the risk-benefit test, once the plaintiff shows the product's design caused the injury, the burden shifts to the manufacturer to prove that the benefits of the design outweigh its inherent risks, considering the gravity and likelihood of harm, the feasibility and cost of a safer alternative design, and that alternative's disadvantages. Barker v. Lull Engineering Co. (1978) created the burden shift, and CACI No. 1204 lists the factors.

Can a retailer be liable for a defective product it did not make?

Yes, California strict liability reaches the commercial chain, so a manufacturer, distributor, or retailer can be liable in tort when a defect in the product's manufacture or design causes injury while the product is being used in a reasonably foreseeable way, even if the retailer never opened or altered the product. Downstream sellers usually respond by tendering to the manufacturer and upstream suppliers under their indemnity and insurance terms.

What is a failure-to-warn claim?

A failure-to-warn claim asserts that a product had potential risks that were known or knowable in light of generally accepted scientific knowledge when it was made or sold, that those risks presented a substantial danger in intended or foreseeable use, that ordinary consumers would not recognize them, and that the warnings or instructions provided were inadequate. CACI No. 1205 sets out the elements.

How should I preserve evidence in a product liability case?

Keep the product exactly as it was after the incident, unwashed, unrepaired, and unaltered, along with the packaging, labels, manuals, receipts, and any broken pieces, photograph everything, record who has handled it, and do not let anyone test or take it apart until all interested parties have been notified and can attend. Destructive testing without notice can create a spoliation dispute that overshadows the defect itself.

How long do I have to file a product liability lawsuit in California?

A product liability lawsuit for personal injury in California generally must be filed within two years under Code of Civil Procedure section 335.1, the statute covering injury or death caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another, so preserving evidence and identifying every company in the chain of distribution should start well before that deadline approaches. Property damage and contract claims can follow different limitation periods.

Where are product liability cases filed in Los Angeles County?

Under Los Angeles Superior Court Local Rule 2.3, an unlimited civil product liability action for bodily injury, other than asbestos or toxic or environmental cases, must be filed in the Central District at the Stanley Mosk Courthouse or in the North District at the Antelope Valley Courthouse, which means a Glendale injury case is not filed at the Glendale Courthouse. The court's filing locator confirms the location for a particular case.

Product liability help in Los Angeles and Glendale

Product cases involving Los Angeles County parties are heard in the county courts or in the federal court for the Central District of California.

Talk to a Litigation Attorney

Preserve the product and tender upstream immediately. Both decisions are difficult to fix later.

Request a consultation(818) 502-1700

330 North Brand Boulevard, Suite 1280, Glendale, CA 91203